Flip-Flop-Flip: McWherter Now Singing Original Tune, Believes Immigration Reform is a Federal Issue
Tuesday, August 24th, 2010Flip-Flop-Flip! Another month has brought us another position on illegal immigration from Democrat Gubernatorial Candidate Mike McWherter. He has changed his talking points on immigration reform yet again, returning to his original position saying immigration reform is a federal issue and that states shouldn’t be involved. His latest flip came while speaking to a local chapter of the Service Employees International Union (SEIU). Each month, Mike McWherter seems to change his talking points on how states should (or should not) approach the issue of illegal immigration. Following shows the flip-flop-flip trip McWherter has been on over the last few months:
| June 9, 2010 | July 7, 2010 | August 19, 2010 |
| His response to a Republican bill passed by the General Assembly praising the state of Arizona for immigration reform legislation:
“Lawmakers want to pass legislation next year emulating Arizona’s immigration law, but not everyone thinks that’s the best course of action. ‘I really think the immigration issue is a federal issue, and what we need is a much better federal policy to protect our borders,’ said Mike McWherter. ‘It’s got to be solved on a federal level.’" (”Gov. Calls Bill Honoring Ariz. Meaningless,” WSMV, 06/09/10) |
His response to President Barack Obama issuing a challenge to Arizona’s new immigration reform legislation:
“‘I think the administration is wrong on this one. Arizona’s trying to get a handle on the immigration policy because of Washington’s total failure to deal with the real problem,’ said Mike McWherter. ‘Immigration has become another political football in Washington and this lawsuit only continues the game, rather than solve the problem. We need to control the border, crack down on businesses that employ illegal workers, and give businesses the tools to quickly and reliably verify a job applicant’s status.” (”Mike McWherter stands up for Ariz. immigration law,” Tennessean Blog, 06/07/10) |
According to an SEIU blog highlighting a McWherter speech to their local chapter:
And while he said that a McWherter Administration would contribute National Guard personnel to help out in every way possible and to make sure that businesses have the tools they need to quickly verify a job applicant’s status, the solution to illegal immigration has to come from the federal government. “We can’t have a patchwork of different laws in different states,” he said. “Washington has to secure the border and get serious about comprehensive reform". (SEIU Blog, 08/20/10) |
Again, which is it Mike? Do you believe that the issue of immigration reform “is a federal issue” and must “be solved on a federal level”? Or do you believe that states should be able to try and “get a handle on the immigration policy because of Washington’s total failure to deal with the real problem”? Or is it a situation in which “We can’t have a patchwork of different laws in different states” and “Washington has to secure the border and get serious about comprehensive reform?”
Unfortunately, it seems that Mike McWherter believes the federal government – despite its failures to combat illegal immigration thus far – can be trusted to address this issue without state involvement. McWherter is demonstrating that as governor, he’ll be leaning on the liberal leadership of President Barack Obama, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and Majority Leader Harry Reid to decide what’s best for Tennessee. That’s not the leadership Tennesseans are looking for.
Tennesseans want an effective leader who will stand up to Washington’s liberal leaders, not rely on their failed policies. Mike McWherter continues to prove he’s not that leader.









